2024 Legislative Session

2024 Legislative Session

The Florida Springs Council was built to level the playing field and win victories for Florida’s springs. Achieving this mission takes many forms, but much of our success over the past five years comes from our ability to fund, manage, and win legal challenges to enforce state environmental laws. Our effectiveness in the courthouse not only impacts the cases we have won, but often prevents us from needing to go to court at all.

This bill would essentially eliminate access to Florida courts for individuals and non-profits that want to protect the environment. HB 789 would saddle the losing party in a case against the Department of Environmental Protection or a water management district with paying the legal fees of the prevailing party, including any corporate intervenors. Only corporations and the wealthiest individuals, who would financially benefit off of the court’s decision, could afford to go to court. This bill is not designed to stop frivolous lawsuits; it is designed to stop public interest lawsuits.

In fact, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency is so concerned about the impact of fee shifting that they have proposed the following rule to clarify existing federal policy:

“A state does not ‘provide for, encourage, and assist’ public participation in the permitting process if State law or regulation requires that attorneys’ fees must be imposed in favor of any prevailing party and against the losing party, notwithstanding the good faith or merit of the litigant’s position. This form of fee shifting would form a barrier to court access for litigants unable to risk an adverse fee award, no matter the strength of their case."

Fill in your own subject line. Suggestions include "HB 789 is Bad for Florida," "Please Don't Agenda HB 789," or "Protect my right to access the courts" 

The Florida Springs Council was built to level the playing field and win victories for Florida’s springs. Achieving this mission takes many forms, but much of our success over the past five years comes from our ability to fund, manage, and win legal challenges to enforce state environmental laws. Our effectiveness in the courthouse not only impacts the cases we have won, but often prevents us from needing to go to court at all.

This bill would essentially eliminate access to Florida courts for individuals and non-profits that want to protect the environment. HB 789 would saddle the losing party in a case against the Department of Environmental Protection or a water management district with paying the legal fees of the prevailing party, including any corporate intervenors. Only corporations and the wealthiest individuals, who would financially benefit off of the court’s decision, could afford to go to court. This bill is not designed to stop frivolous lawsuits; it is designed to stop public interest lawsuits.

In fact, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency is so concerned about the impact of fee shifting that they have proposed the following rule to clarify existing federal policy:

“A state does not ‘provide for, encourage, and assist’ public participation in the permitting process if State law or regulation requires that attorneys’ fees must be imposed in favor of any prevailing party and against the losing party, notwithstanding the good faith or merit of the litigant’s position. This form of fee shifting would form a barrier to court access for litigants unable to risk an adverse fee award, no matter the strength of their case."

Fill in your own subject line. Suggestions include "HB 789 is Bad for Florida," "Please Don't Agenda HB 789," or "Protect my right to access the courts" 

Keep HB 789 off the House Water Quality, Supply & Treatment Subcommittee Agenda

Where do you live?

Compose your email

Email Tips +

Fill in your own subject line. Suggestions include "HB 789 is Bad for Florida," "Please Don't Agenda HB 789," or "Protect my right to access the courts"